June 8, 2004: The D-Day celebrations on the 60th
anniversary of the historic Normandy landing provided the
German press an opportunity to reflect on the strain in
relations between Europe and the United States. The
"Süddeutsche Zeitung" commented on the situation in an
editorial titled "The mortal gods":
"There were millions of people in Europe who had longed for
this day and who drew strength from it to continue ... the
appearance of the tall, well-fed, casual U. S. soldiers [was
compared] to the landing of the gods on Europe's shores: A free
breed of people – generous, kind, noble, unaffected by
Europe's hate – came from the new world, not only to free
the old world, but also to heal her of her crimes.
"Of course, these mortal gods paid a terrible price in blood
on the day of the invasion and in the following weeks ... the
survivors still talk today with tears in their eyes about their
fallen comrades, who often died just a few meters away. But
most have the feeling that the sacrifices of battle were worth
it. Europe was freed from a terrible tyranny, and as a result
of the American victory and the ensuing aid Europe was changed
in its entire being.
"The years of the fight against Hitler were, as Thomas Mann
once said reflectively, a good time for the soul because it was
a morally clear time. This clarity made it possible in the
first place for the Americans to take the great sacrifice of
the war upon themselves – otherwise they would never have
mingled in Europe's quarrels ...
"The celebrations on this weekend for the 60th anniversary
of the invasion take place in a depressingly different
constellation. The acceptance of the German chancellor among
the celebrants once again underscores the clear victory of the
west in 1945. But the mood of ten years ago right after the
victory in the Cold War is gone. That victory left the United
States as the only world power. At the same time, Russia's loss
of strength reduced the pressure on Europeans to lean on
America. The forces that bind the West have decreased.
"The U.S.A. has contributed a lot to that in recent years.
The image of the American soldier has never been so besmirched
in the history of the United States. The war against Saddam
Hussein was clearly in violation of international law and
thereby subject to greater moral requirements – as a
battle for democratic values and desired ways of life. But a
mixture of dilettantism, arrogance and lack of interest for
foreign culture has made a failure out of the Iraq
adventure ...
"On this weekend in Normandy, George W. Bush will try to
regain some of the moral force of the days 60 years ago and to
renew the idea of a west that spans the Atlantic ... Europeans
can only hope that America gets back in this [moral] shape. The
English historian Niall Ferguson has just written a brilliant
analysis 'Imperium denied' showing the dangers of America
retreating within itself: a world state of international loss
of order such as there has not been in centuries.
"American moralism in the form of para-religious
fundamentalism is a threatening stance for the world. But
without the American sense of mission entire regions of the
world would sink into greater chaos. June 6 gives Europeans a
timely job: They have to remind the American giant gone
hysterical of his better self, his lawfulness and nonchalance,
his liberal optimism with which he once won the world."
In its editorial "Lessons from D-Day", the "Nürnberger
Nachrichten" had this to say about the historic weekend:
"It was a day that changed the world. June 6, 1944 is not
only the historic date when 150,000 Allied soldiers landed in
Normandy in the greatest amphibious landing in history and
began to free France from its German occupation. As we know
today, 'D-Day' changed the political and military balance far
beyond Europe, and the tangible results are still visible some
60 years later.
"Military historians may argue over which event is the real
turning point of World War II – whether it the Russian
victories in Stalingrad and west of Moscow contributed more to
taking down the Wehrmacht. One thing is for sure: the Normandy
landing sealed the collapse of Hitler-Germany and gave Europe
its current contour. Without American soldiers on the
continent, without the speedy conquest of western Germany by
allied troops, the advance of the Red Army to the Rhine would
have been unstoppable and there would not have been a Federal
Republic of Germany. The face of Europe would look
different.
"Europe's liberation from the Nazis would hardly have been
possible without American GIs and without the gigantic armament
shipments from the U.S.A to the drained Soviets and British.
America did not only change the old world – it, too, was
changed. With the Normandy invasion the United States
indisputably assumed the leadership role in the west. 60 years
later it is the only remaining superpower on the globe –
simultaneously controversial, powerful and helpless.
"June 6, 2004 is therefore not only a day of remembrance,
but also day of reflection for the Americans and their allies.
For nothing is the same as it once was. America's soldiers are
no longer celebrated as liberators. The GIs in Iraq are met
with raw hate and the superpower has incurred the anger of the
Moslem world. Even traditional allies turn away in
disappointment from their former example. Transatlantic
relations have reached a low point, as has the moral standing
of the U.S.A. ever since the pictures of torture from Abu
Ghraib circulated around the world.
"During these days George W. Bush likes to invoke the
'spirit of 1944', with which American soldiers 'first freed
Europe and now Iraq.' But his obvious attempt to link both wars
(and himself with Roosevelt) is actually embarassing. For one
thing, the Nazi barbarity was unique historically, making any
comparison with Saddam Hussein erroneous. And through the
Normandy landing Roosevelt really did bring peace to Europe and
create the prerequisites for a more just world order. By
intervening militarily in Iraq, Bush has done peace a
disservice, contributed to further destabilization of the
explosive Middle East and made the battle against terror
– the greatest threat to freedom and democracy today
– more difficult" (June 5, 2004).